P. Auster, 4 3 2 1 (2017)
E. Fridlund, History of Wolves (2017)
M. Hamid, Exit West (2017)
P. Lock, The Franks in the Aegean: 1204-1500 (1995)
P. Lock, The Franks in the Aegean: 1204-1500 (1995)
F. Mozley, Elmet (2017)
G. Saunders, Lincoln in the Bardo (2017)
A. Smith, Autumn (2017)
G. Saunders, Lincoln in the Bardo (2017)
A. Smith, Autumn (2017)
I gave myself a few extra days to finish Auster so I could fit the whole Booker shortlist in one month, especially as - miracle of miracles - it's before the announcement of the winner. He seems to have written (very nicely; and in far too many words) Sliding Doors - it was a lot better than I'd feared and it's certainly my favourite Auster (this is easy; I hate pretty much everything else of his I've read).
Overall, it was a pretty good Booker list, with only Ali Smith really not up to it - her Brexit stuff was extremely clumsy. Everyone says Lincoln in the Bardo is going to win, but I thought it was nowhere near as clever or profound as everyone else, and the citations seem to be trying to make the same point as GCSE History about unreliable evidence. I had a few issues with Hamid because the high concept sneaks up on you, but then I thought it was great. The start especially is very good. Mozley also sagged slightly in the middle, but was genuinely gripping and a rare evocation of a raw, less civilised, world, just occasionally poking through the cracks of ours. It wasn't cheery, but it was powerful. It was my favourite.
Ranked as below:
- Mozley
- Hamid
- Auster
- Saunders
- Fridlund
- Smith
Not one of them made BOTM. That was Piketty, which I loved. It's not the book I expected it to be at all. It's got hard, real data in. I've referred to it in endless conversations already and I expect to keep coming back to it. It has flaws - its policy solutions are weaker than the analysis - but the good bits (which is most of it) are very very good. The data should be essential reading for any wider discussion about inequality and wealth. It won't be.
No comments:
Post a Comment